Apparently 80% of single Christian young adults in America are having sex outside of marriage. Another study states that apparently only 11% of Christians are waiting until they’re married. Now, I’m not good at math, but even I’m not sure what happened to the other 9%. But we’re just going to go ahead and assume that these numbers are somewhat accurate. Because they’re not at all surprising.
Let’s be honest here. Looking outside of Christian circles, pretty much everyone really is doing it. It’s everywhere. It’s glorified in movies like 50 Shades of Grey. Even networks with names such as “ABC Family” (which, once upon a time, would have been synonymous with “no sex”), air tv shows that explicitly talk about the characters having casual sex with each other as if it’s no big deal at all, and it makes them happy, cool, and normal. Their parents give them condoms, make sure they know better than to end up pregnant, and then turn a blind eye while their 15 year-old kids have sexual relationships, sometimes in their own homes.
Whether one agrees with sex outside of marriage or not, the immersion of sex in our culture is an objective truth.
Because of that, there has been an increasingly loud voice from the opposite end of the spectrum, known as the purity culture. Born of the need to push back against the effects of the sexual revolution, and fostered in books like 1997’s “I Kissed Dating Goodbye”, and songs like “Wait For Me”, its cry usually sounds something like “true love waits”.
Its objective is good: teach youth and young adults that they don’t have to give in to the peer pressure of the mainstream media, or of their friends. Teach them that the ramifications are not worth it. Teach them that God made sex, and that He made sex good, but He made it for the confines of marriage.
Yeah, that sounds good so far.
Give them purity rings, have them sign pledges to stay virgins until their wedding nights, have purity balls, bring in speakers to teach them about courtship, and that saving your first kiss until marriage is even better. Holier, even.
Wait, what?
No. Just no.
This is where it self-destructs. Virginity and purity are put on such high pedestals, they come dangerously close to resembling the likes of that golden calf at the foot of Mount Sinai. And such unattainable ideals as not kissing until your wedding day only rob teenage girls of the normal elation that they should feel when they experience their first kiss, and instead make them feel like failures because they didn’t wait until they said “I do”. And what exactly do we mean by “true love waits”? If you give in to temptation, because you’re a normal human being, it can’t possibly be true love? If you didn’t wait, you’ll never find true love?
Then there are the rules. The rules are endless, and depend on which talk you went to in which year, at which youth rally or conference: Don’t be alone with guys; date in groups; don’t pray with him because he will just take advantage of the emotional intimacy to lure you in (because men are weak, oh but they should still lead the relationship); don’t let him hold your hand or sit too close on the couch; don’t spend too much time alone in the car; don’t dance too close, maybe don’t dance at all; don’t kiss, and if you do, for God’s sake, keep it under 2 seconds, and don’t use your tongue…the list goes on, and it’s next to impossible to decipher, let alone live up to. (Unless you are a member of a certain reality show family with more children than a basketball team, and your parents go on dates with you and read all of your text messages. But even then, the rules are being followed for them, not by their own free choice.)
It’s too much. It’s too confusing. It’s too unrealistic. And it’s all we ever talk about.
I think 80% have just said to hell with it all, and thrown in the towel.
Honestly, as a 26 year old young adult in Catholic circles, I can tell you that this stat doesn’t surprise me. While the exact number may not be completely accurate, I don’t think it’s too far off. Perhaps these rules work to keep some teenagers from having sex way too young. But eventually you hit your twenties, and you become an adult in the real world, and so do all of your friends. And you watch people give in to these things, and they’re people who you never thought would. Even people on whom you may have counted to be some sort of moral compass for you. And yet they aren’t struck by lightning. In fact, they go on and live happy, fulfilled lives, with what certainly seems like (GASP) true love, despite having given in. And that makes you question everything.
And it doesn’t help that nobody ever talks about that 80%. Too often, during these purity talks, it seems like it is just assumed that everyone present is all on the same level of sexual experience and, by that, I mean none. Those who have experience, whether they regret it or not, are left to squirm in their seats, smiling and nodding, and trying desperately to fit into the mould, feeling like the only one in the room who doesn’t. Just once, I would like to walk into a young adults talk, and have the speaker start off by asking for a show of hands of people who are sexually active, and when half or more of the attendees raise their hands, then let’s see what the aura is in the room. And then let’s maybe talk about something different for once.
Because here’s a newsflash: young adults in the church are sick of hearing about sex, and what they should and shouldn’t do. Maybe not all of them, but I know I can’t be alone in this. Part of the problem is that some of the people organizing these conferences and things, while young adults themselves, have been married since they were 19 or 20. And while I’m sincerely happy for them that they have found their spouse and their happily ever after, in my opinion, they don’t necessarily relate to the post-college-age single crowd. There is more to Christian life than sex, so please stop forcing us to think about it. If you want to keep us interested in a conference, give us something else to work with. There are so many topics that have nothing to do with sex and marriage, and actually apply to most of us. Like, for instance, ethics in the workplace, or some good old apologetics. But you don’t need a token purity talk, or a theology of the body teaching in order to have a successful young adults event. Just leave us alone already. Or better yet, make it real. Tell us how to live Christian lives even though most of us won’t be virgins on our wedding nights. Acknowledge that fact. But if you’re just going to tell us how hugs are possible occasion for sin, and how we need to be shining examples of purity for all the world to see, find another topic.
Because clearly, we’re caving under the pressure.